Haig Partners Reports Mixed Dealership Valuations as Blue Sky Values Decline 10.4%

Haig Partners Reports 10.4% Decline in Dealership Blue Sky Values Amid Growing Franchise Valuation Gap

The U.S. automotive dealership industry is experiencing a period of changing valuations, declining profitability and shifting acquisition strategies, according to the newly released Q3 2026 Haig Report® from Haig Partners. The report highlights a 10.4% decline in the estimated average blue sky value of publicly owned dealerships over the trailing 12 months through the third quarter of 2026. Despite the decline, premium dealership franchises continue to attract significant interest from investors and buyers, creating a widening gap between the industry’s strongest and weaker-performing brands.

The average blue sky value per publicly owned dealership declined to approximately $17 million, compared with $19 million in 2025. Blue sky represents the intangible value of a dealership beyond its tangible assets, including goodwill, franchise rights, customer relationships and future earning potential. Although valuations have decreased, current values remain approximately twice their pre-pandemic levels.

Dealership profitability is also facing pressure. Adjusted pre-tax income among publicly owned dealerships declined 14.9% in Q3 2026 compared with the same quarter in 2025. However, the performance of individual automotive brands varies considerably, with buyers increasingly prioritizing franchises that demonstrate stronger profitability, customer demand and long-term growth prospects.

According to Alan Haig, President and Founder of Haig Partners, the dealership industry continues to perform reasonably well despite several economic and operational challenges. He noted that buyers remain willing to pay substantial premiums for franchises they believe will deliver stronger performance in the future. This growing preference for established and profitable brands is contributing to a significant difference in dealership valuations.

Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Toyota Receive Higher Valuation Multiples

One of the most important findings in the Q3 2026 Haig Report® is the increase in estimated blue sky valuation multiples for four major automotive franchises: Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Toyota.

Haig Partners increased the estimated valuation ranges for these brands based on their profitability, market positions, product strategies, factory relationships and buyer demand.

The updated valuation ranges are:

  • Lexus: 10.0x–12.0x – Lexus maintains the highest estimated blue sky multiple in the automotive dealership industry. Its limited dealership availability, strong profitability and positive manufacturer relationships continue to support premium valuations.
  • Mercedes-Benz: 9.0x–10.0x – Strong acquisition demand, confidence in factory leadership, an improving product portfolio and an electric vehicle strategy more closely aligned with consumer preferences have supported the increase.
  • BMW: 8.5x–10.0x – A competitive product pipeline, balanced powertrain strategy and continued confidence in its position within the luxury automotive market have strengthened buyer interest.
  • Toyota: 8.0x–10.0x – High vehicle sales volumes, strong gross profits and excellent manufacturer-dealer relationships continue to make Toyota dealerships attractive acquisition opportunities.

However, not all automotive brands experienced improved valuations. Haig Partners lowered its estimated valuation ranges for Subaru, Mazda and Hyundai-Genesis. It also reduced the upper end of Volkswagen’s estimated dollar-value range.

The report points to limited hybrid vehicle offerings among some of the brands experiencing weaker valuations. As consumer demand increasingly shifts toward fuel-efficient and hybrid vehicles, franchises with less competitive product portfolios may face challenges in maintaining market share.

These differences demonstrate that dealership buyers are becoming more selective. Rather than evaluating all automotive franchises similarly, investors are increasingly focusing on brands with strong sales performance, attractive margins, reliable manufacturer relationships and sustainable business models.

For dealership owners considering a sale, higher valuation multiples also create an opportunity to understand the full range of potential buyers before accepting an offer. Haig Partners emphasizes that an unsolicited offer from one buyer does not necessarily represent the highest possible market value of a dealership.

Dealership Profitability Declines Amid Higher Costs and Consumer Affordability Challenges

The report identifies several factors contributing to declining dealership profitability, including tighter vehicle margins, weaker finance and insurance income, rising operating expenses and slower growth in fixed operations.

The average publicly owned dealership generated approximately $900,000 in adjusted pre-tax income during Q3 2026. This represents a 14.9% decrease compared with Q3 2025 and marks the lowest third-quarter result since 2019.

Over the trailing 12 months, adjusted earnings declined 11.4% to approximately $3.6 million per dealership. Nevertheless, earnings remained 72.7% above 2019 levels, demonstrating that dealerships continue to operate at considerably higher profitability levels than before the COVID-19 pandemic.

Fixed operations, which include vehicle servicing, maintenance, repairs and parts sales, have traditionally provided dealerships with a relatively stable source of income. However, growth in this segment has also slowed.

Same-store fixed operations gross profit increased just 0.6% during the first nine months of 2026, falling behind inflation. This development could create additional challenges for dealers that depend on service and parts operations to offset weaker vehicle sales margins.

Dealership property valuations are also experiencing pressure. According to the report, sale-leaseback companies are now evaluating dealership properties using capitalization rates of approximately 7.5% to 8.0%, compared with 6.5% to 7.0% in previous years.

Higher capitalization rates generally result in lower property valuations for the same rental income. Consequently, dealership owners considering property sales or sale-leaseback transactions may need to reassess their financial expectations.

Consumer affordability is another major challenge affecting automotive retail. According to the Cox Automotive/Moody’s Analytics Vehicle Affordability Index, the average monthly payment for a new vehicle reached $776 in September 2026, its highest level since December 2023.

Edmunds data also indicated that 21.2% of new vehicle buyers took on monthly payments of at least $1,000. Additionally, 25.5% of new vehicle loans carried repayment terms of 84 months or longer.

These figures highlight the increasing financial pressure on vehicle buyers. Higher vehicle prices, financing costs and ownership expenses are encouraging some consumers to postpone purchases or consider more affordable models.

According to Cox Automotive, retail vehicle sales declined 5% through September 2026, while fleet sales increased 7%.

Dealerships must therefore manage a combination of lower retail demand, tighter margins and higher operating costs. Businesses that control expenses, improve operational efficiency and strengthen customer retention may be better positioned to maintain profitability.

Private Buyers Drive Dealership Acquisitions as Luxury Transactions Increase

Despite declining profitability and lower average blue sky values, dealership acquisition activity remained relatively strong during the first nine months of 2026.

A total of 455 dealerships changed ownership through September, representing a 3.8% decrease from the 473 acquisitions recorded during the same period in 2025.

However, the comparison is influenced by Asbury Automotive Group’s acquisition of the 43-dealership Herb Chambers group in 2025. Excluding that major transaction, dealership acquisitions increased 5.8% year over year.

Private buyers continued to dominate the acquisition market, completing 439 dealership acquisitions, an increase of 8.7% compared with the previous year.

Meanwhile, publicly traded dealership groups were net sellers during the reporting period, reflecting a growing preference for returning capital to shareholders through stock repurchases rather than pursuing acquisitions at elevated prices.

Luxury dealership acquisitions experienced particularly strong growth. Excluding the Herb Chambers transaction, acquisitions of luxury dealerships increased 43.7% compared with the previous year.

Import dealership acquisitions increased 27.0%, while domestic dealership acquisitions declined 7.8%.

The exotic vehicle franchise segment also recorded substantial growth, with 24 dealerships changing ownership compared with just nine during the same period in 2025.

Regional activity varied across the United States. The Southeast and California recorded particularly strong acquisition growth, with dealership purchases increasing 40.0% and 50.0%, respectively.

Publicly traded dealership groups also adjusted their capital allocation strategies. AutoNation and Lithia each spent approximately $600 million on share repurchases through September 2026, roughly twice their spending on dealership acquisitions.

Lithia indicated that elevated acquisition prices had made share repurchases a more attractive use of available capital.

These developments highlight an important change in the dealership M&A market. Private investors remain active, particularly in attractive luxury and import franchises, while publicly traded groups are becoming more disciplined about acquisition costs and investment returns.

Franchise Horsepower Index Provides Additional Insight Into Dealership Values

Beyond traditional blue sky valuation multiples, Haig Partners uses its proprietary Franchise Horsepower Index™ to evaluate the revenue-generating performance of automotive franchises.

The index measures average new vehicle revenue per dealership using sales volumes and average transaction prices during the first nine months of 2026.

The Q3 2026 report identifies the following leading franchises:

  • Lexus: 2.42x
  • BMW: 2.13x
  • Toyota: 2.04x
  • Mercedes-Benz: 1.68x

These results demonstrate the strong new vehicle revenue performance of the leading luxury and mainstream automotive franchises relative to the industry average.

The index also provides insight into differences between brands that generate similar levels of dealership revenue but receive different acquisition multiples.

For example, Kia and Hyundai-Genesis recorded nearly identical Franchise Horsepower Index scores of 1.14x and 1.13x, respectively.

However, Kia’s estimated blue sky valuation multiple midpoint is 1.25 turns higher than Hyundai-Genesis.

According to Haig Partners, differences in dealer perceptions of manufacturer relationships account for much of this valuation gap.

The Franchise Horsepower Index is designed to help dealership buyers understand the relationship between a franchise’s revenue-generating potential and its acquisition cost.

A higher valuation multiple indicates that buyers are paying more for a dealership’s intangible value, while the index provides additional information about the revenue generated by its new vehicle operations.

This comparison can help investors identify opportunities where dealership economics may be stronger than the valuation multiple initially suggests.

Kia Dealership Performance Improves With Strong Vehicle Sales Growth

The Q3 2026 Haig Report® also includes an in-depth analysis of Kia, highlighting the brand’s progress in vehicle sales, dealership performance and acquisition demand.

The average Kia dealership sold approximately 1,106 new vehicles over the trailing 12 months, representing a 37.3% increase compared with 2019.

During this period, Kia narrowly outsold Nissan in the United States and continued to reduce the sales gap with Honda.

The brand’s improved market position has strengthened its importance within the automotive retail industry.

In addition to new vehicle sales, Haig Partners identifies fixed operations as a potential source of future growth for Kia dealerships.

The number of Kia vehicles in operation increased 18.2% between 2022 and 2025. A growing vehicle population creates additional opportunities for dealership service departments to generate revenue through maintenance, repairs and replacement parts.

As more Kia vehicles remain on the road, dealerships could benefit from a larger customer base requiring aftersales services.

For dealership investors, this combination of vehicle sales growth and expanding service opportunities may create additional long-term value.

Northeast Dealership Market Sees Private Buyers Dominate Acquisitions

The report also examines dealership acquisition activity across the Northeast United States, which includes nine states and represents an important automotive retail market.

The region contains approximately 3,204 franchised new-car dealerships, accounting for 18.9% of all franchised dealerships nationwide. These businesses generated approximately $231 billion in sales during 2025.

However, dealership acquisition activity in the Northeast slowed during the first nine months of 2026.

A total of 50 dealerships were acquired through Q3 2026, compared with 77 during the same period in 2025, excluding Asbury Automotive Group’s acquisition of the Herb Chambers dealership group.

Private buyers accounted for 49 of the 50 reported dealership acquisitions, demonstrating their dominant position in the regional M&A market.

Haig Partners also advised New Country on the sale of three Northeast dealerships to Open Road Capital. The transaction included Lexus of Westport and Toyota of Westport in Connecticut, along with Audi Hawthorne in New York.

The report further highlights differences in brand performance across the Northeast.

Volvo, Acura, Subaru, INFINITI and BMW recorded some of the highest regional market shares relative to their respective national averages.

Their market share ratios were:

  • Volvo: 1.9x
  • Acura: 1.7x
  • Subaru: 1.7x
  • INFINITI: 1.5x
  • BMW: 1.4x

These differences reflect regional demographics, weather conditions and consumer preferences. They can also influence acquisition strategies, dealership profitability and franchise valuations.

Haig Partners Announces Maximizing Value Conference for February 2027

Alongside its latest industry analysis, Haig Partners announced plans to host its Maximizing Value Conference™ on February 17, 2027, at the Hyatt Regency Orlando in Florida.

The dealer-only conference will take place in conjunction with the NADA Show and will operate under the theme “Maximizing Profits Today. Investing for Growth Tomorrow.”

The event will bring together automotive dealership owners and industry professionals to discuss dealership profitability, franchise acquisition opportunities, economic developments and changing automotive retail trends.

Technology and artificial intelligence are also expected to feature in discussions about the future of dealership operations.

The conference aims to help dealership leaders understand how to improve current business performance while identifying opportunities for sustainable growth and stronger long-term valuations.

Automotive Dealership Industry Faces a More Selective M&A Market

The Q3 2026 Haig Report® highlights an important transition in the automotive dealership industry. Although average blue sky values and dealership earnings have declined, acquisition demand remains strong for brands with attractive financial performance and promising long-term prospects.

Lexus, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Toyota continue to benefit from higher valuation multiples, while several other franchises face greater pressure from changing consumer preferences and competitive challenges.

Private buyers remain important participants in dealership acquisitions, particularly in the luxury and import segments. Meanwhile, publicly traded groups are becoming more selective about acquisitions and increasingly directing capital toward share repurchases.

Rising vehicle payments, operating expenses and financing costs will remain important challenges for dealerships. At the same time, expanding vehicle populations, stronger fixed operations and improved operational efficiency could provide opportunities for future growth.

For dealership owners, the findings reinforce the importance of understanding franchise-specific valuations and the broader buyer market before making major business decisions.

As the industry moves forward, dealership value will increasingly depend on brand strength, profitability, manufacturer relationships, product competitiveness and the ability to generate sustainable revenue beyond new vehicle sales.

Source Link:https://www.businesswire.com/